Book Review: A Life Too Short - The Tragedy of Robert Enke
Published: August 11, 2016

Most people read the autobiographies of sports people to gain a better understanding of their heroes, to find out what makes them tick – what drives them to be successful. The importance of Ronald Reng's biography of German goalkeeper Robert Enke is not in how it captures him on the field, but in how it chronicles his life and his battle with depression off it.


The story of Robert Enke is both tragic and distressing. It represented further proof, not that it should be needed , that footballers at the highest level are susceptible to mental health issues such as depression despite the glamorous lifestyles most lead, and that those of us on the outside can only dream of. Enke and his family and friends tried to hide his depression throughout his career, fearing public awareness of his condition would damage his reputation.


That they felt the need to take that course of action speaks volumes of the pressure professionals in any elite sport have to contend with. German football had already seen a high profile player suffer with depression. Sebastian Deisler was reckoned to be Germany's great white hope at the turn of the millennium having lit up the Bundesliga with Borussia Monchengladbach and Hertha Berlin.


Instead, Deisler arrived at Bayern Munich in 2002 on the back of successive knee injuries and would suffer at least one more major one which would restrict him to just 86 appearances in four and a half years. Deisler would also suffer bouts of depression for which he was treated in both 2003 and 2004. He would ultimately retire in 2007 and would later cite the pressure he was under at Bayern as a factor in his depression.


The importance of A Life Too Short in relation to raising mental health awareness should not be underestimated. It is a cautionary tale not only for high level professional athletes of all disciplines but for people in general given the number of lives that have been affected by this illness.


The author, Ronald Reng, was a close confidante of Enke's for much of his football career and we find out in the book that it was very important to Enke that he be able to tell his story someday. His intention, perhaps, was to tell it after he had retired, after he had escaped the pressures of the Bundesliga and the German national team.


“Today I know why the biography was so close to his heart,” Reng writes in a Life Too Short. “When his goalkeeping career was over, he would finally be able to talk about his illness. In our achievement-orientated society a goalkeeper, the last bastion in defence, can't be a depressive. So Robert summoned up a huge amount of strength to keep his depression secret. He locked himself away in his illness. So I will now have to tell his story without him.”


Enke took his own life on November 10th, 2009. He was playing for Hannover 96 at the time and was expected to be Germany's first choice goalkeeper at the 2010 World Cup in South Africa. He had been battling depression for six years, unknown to the wider public. His death came at a time when the suicide rate in Germany was increasing.


The fact that he committed suicide is important, but not as important as the fact that he had a life. The real tragedy is that Enke will always be associated with how he died; that how the things which really matter – his family, his ability as a goalkeeper, what he achieved at the clubs he played for and what he was really like as a person – are all considered secondarily or not at all by those who didn't know him.


Therefore, the balance Reng achieves in this book is an incredible one. He portrays the man and presents the obstacles he faced, both professionally and personally, while trying to plot a course through his friend's mental state with sensitivity and remarkable restraint – and without ever becoming too emotionally involved.


Even though Reng himself became an increasingly big part of Enke's life, he never intrudes on the narrative. Instead he uses the words of Enke's family, friends and colleagues – as well as quotes from the man himself, some so stark they can be difficult to read when put into the context of his death – to lay out Enke's life as it happened. The good times and the bad.


In this way, the readers can see the tell-tale signs of depression that too often are evident only after the fact. They may learn to recognise them in others or even in themselves. This can make all the difference. As Reng wrote himself, “It would be too much to hope that the illness will be understood all of a sudden. But perhaps this book will do something to help depressives find more sympathy and understanding.”


There is one more quote from the book which I wish to reproduce because I feel it is one of the most important. It is in relation to Toni Madrigal, a Spanish striker who would play a major part in one of Enke's lowest career points, a cup game between Barcelona – Enke's club at the time – and Segunda B side FC Novelda, which the latter won 3-2, Madrigal netting a hat-trick.


“Toni Madrigal doesn't believe that one game can transform a football career. But, he adds, thinking about Robert Enke, one evening can mark a life.”

Leave a Comment

Fran Reilly

Fran Reilly joined in February 2015 having previously written for the Drogheda/Fingal Independents, and the Cork City matchday programme. Though only part of the ET family for a relatively short time, the Donaghmede native has already had the opportunity to cover League of Ireland clubs both domestically and in Europe, as well as Republic of Ireland internationals. He can count Martin O'Neill, Roy Keane and Dutch footballing legend Ruud Gullit amongst those he has come face-to-face with during his line of ET work. He still hopes to someday meet Henrik Larsson.

Fran was once sent to watch Lionel Messi play in the Aviva Stadium for Barcelona but left feeling underwhelmed as his performance fell some way short of replicating Wes Hoolahan's against Deportivo la Coruna in August 2004. That famous night was enough to make Fran a Shels fan and he even pulled on the red shirt himself once for Owen Heary's tribute match in November 2013. Hilariously, he saw a penalty saved by unforgiving goalkeeper Lee Murphy, then at Bohemians.

His one day spell as a member of the Extratime media six-a-side panel fared no better, his status as a reporter coming under threat following a string of less than inspirational performances. However, he convinced the ET hierarchy to persevere with him so he lingers on, covering whatever clubs he can reach by public transport. You can follow Fran on Twitter (@FranTomReilly) where he spends most of his time retweeting other people's LOI views and news and claiming them as his own.

More articles from Fran Reilly

image description Photographer: Harold Cunningham/UEFA

Book Review: Gods Vs Mortals by Paul Keane

by Fran Reilly on Sat, Sep 10 2016

In light of Dundalk's recent European adventure, a review of a book chronicling the greatest exploits of all League of ...... Read more

image description Photographer: Matt Kirkham

League Preview: Cork City -v- Longford Town

by Fran Reilly on Fri, Aug 26 2016

Having met in the FAI Cup just six days ago at the City Calling Stadium, Cork City and Longford Town ...... Read more

image description Photographer: Tom Beary

FAI Cup Preview: Bohemians -v- Derry City

by Fran Reilly on Thu, Aug 18 2016

Bohemians' last outing in this competition saw them end a seven game goalless streak as they defeated Galway United 2-0 ...... Read more

image description

Book Review: A Life Too Short - The Tragedy of Robert Enke

by Fran Reilly on Thu, Aug 11 2016

The importance of Ronald Reng's biography of German goalkeeper Robert Enke is not in how it captures him on the ...... Read more

image description Photographer: Eoin Smith

League Report: Shelbourne 1 - 2 UCD

by Fran Reilly on Sat, Aug 06 2016

Second-half goals from Gary O'Neill and Jason McClelland secured UCD a 2-1 win over Shelbourne at Tolka Park which sees ...... Read more

image description Photographer: Eddie Lennon

Cormac Raftery leaves Galway United

by Fran Reilly on Thu, Aug 04 2016

Raftery signed for Galway from Salthill Devon mid-way through the 2014 campaign and became part of the squad which won ...... Read more